The 10 best holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines, USA | Booking.com
Skip to main content

Holiday Rentals in Fire Island Pines

Find the holiday rentals that appeal to you the most

The best holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines

Check out our pick of great holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines

Show hotels on map

Filter by:

Review score

The Pines Men-Only Stay

Fire Island Pines

The Pines Men-Only Stay is a recently renovated homestay in Fire Island Pines, where guests can make the most of its outdoor swimming pool and terrace.

C
Cary Lee Wade
From
South Africa
Absolute gem in the Pines 🌊🔥 From the moment we arrived, this property delivered the kind of stay you hope for on Fire Island and rarely get all at once. The home is gorgeous—immaculately kept, stylish without trying too hard—and the heated pool became our daily ritual. Beds? Massive, cloud-level comfortable. We slept like babies after sunset boardwalk strolls. There’s also a proper gym on site, so we could offset all the “vacation decisions” we made at dinner. 😅 What really sets this place apart is the host. Warm, proactive, genuinely thoughtful—the kind of hospitality that feels effortless because it’s real. He even made me an iced coffee (I’m usually not a fan) that was so good I asked for the recipe. Communication was smooth end-to-end and check-in/check-out were a breeze. If you’re debating where to stay in the Pines, this is your sign. Beautiful property, heated pool, huge comfy beds, gym for the motivated—and a host who turns a great trip into an unforgettable one. We’ll be back. 🇿🇦❤️
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3
Superb - What previous guests thought, 45 reviews
Price from
US$168
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Sea La Vie

Ocean Beach (Near Fire Island Pines)

Featuring a hot tub, Sea La Vie is set in Ocean Beach. This holiday home offers accommodation with a patio.

Scored out of 10, guest rating 6.4
Pleasant - What previous guests thought, 9 reviews
Check availability
All holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines

Most booked holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines and surroundings in the past month

See all

Highly rated holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines and nearby

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.8
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 41 reviews

    Come As You Are Inn LLC in Sayville provides adults-only accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a garden and a bar. A hot tub is available for guests.

    From US$228.50 per night

These holiday rentals in Fire Island Pines and nearby have options with free cancellation

  • 10 Cayuga

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available

    10 Cayuga is set in Ocean Bay Park, 300 metres from Ocean Beach, 33 km from Nikon Theater, and 33 km from Jones Beach State Park.

  • Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.5
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews

    Set 400 metres from Ocean Beach, 33 km from Nikon Theater and 33 km from Jones Beach State Park, Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat offers accommodation located in Ocean Bay Park.

  • 15 Seneca

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 10.0
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews

    Featuring air-conditioned accommodation with a private pool, 15 Seneca is set in Ocean Bay Park. Guests can benefit from a patio and a picnic area.

  • Pura Vida

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 5.5
    Passable - What previous guests thought, 4 reviews

    Featuring accommodation with a terrace, Pura Vida is located in Ocean Bay Park. Guests staying at this holiday home have access to a balcony. The property has a restaurant with an outdoor dining area.

  • Poolside Chic by the Sea

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 5.0
    Passable - What previous guests thought, 1 review

    Situated in Ocean Bay Park, 200 metres from Ocean Beach and 33 km from Nikon Theater, Poolside Chic by the Sea features a restaurant and sea views.

  • The Surfcomber Condos

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.5
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews

    Featuring a restaurant, The Surfcomber Condos is set in Ocean Bay Park in the New York region, 300 metres from Ocean Beach and 33 km from Nikon Theater.

  • 37 Ocean Bay Blvd

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 4.0
    Disappointing - What previous guests thought, 1 review

    Set in Ocean Bay Park in the New York region, 37 Ocean Bay Blvd features a patio. This beachfront property offers access to a balcony. The property has a restaurant with an outdoor dining area.

  • Fire Island Gem

    Ocean Bay Park
    Free cancellation options available
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.0
    Superb - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews

    Situated in Ocean Bay Park in the New York region, Fire Island Gem features a patio.

Enjoy breakfast in Fire Island Pines and nearby

  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.5
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 4 reviews

    Situated in Ocean Bay Park, 70 metres from Ocean Beach and 33 km from Nikon Theater, Huron Hideaway offers air conditioning.

  • Set 90 metres from Ocean Beach, 33 km from Nikon Theater and 33 km from Jones Beach State Park, Seaside Escape on Huron offers accommodation situated in Ocean Beach.

    From US$1,262.63 per night
  • Scored out of 10, guest rating 5.0
    Passable - What previous guests thought, 1 review

    Set in Ocean Bay Park, Casa de Zeus features accommodation 200 metres from Ocean Beach. The property has a restaurant with an outdoor dining area.

  • 26 Duneway

    Ocean Beach
    Breakfast options
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 6.0
    Pleasant - What previous guests thought, 3 reviews

    Boasting accommodation with a balcony, 26 Duneway is situated in Ocean Beach. Guests can benefit from a terrace and a children's playground.

  • Located in Ocean Beach in the New York region, Seaclusion Gardens features a patio.

  • Featuring accommodation with a balcony, 195 Wilmot Road is located in Ocean Beach. Guests can benefit from a terrace and a children's playground.

  • Paradiso

    Ocean Beach
    Breakfast options
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 10.0
    Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 1 review

    Paradiso is located in Ocean Beach, 33 km from Nikon Theater, 33 km from Jones Beach State Park, and 23 km from Bergen Point County Golf Course.

  • Sea La Vie

    Ocean Beach
    Breakfast options
    Scored out of 10, guest rating 6.4
    Pleasant - What previous guests thought, 9 reviews

    Featuring a hot tub, Sea La Vie is set in Ocean Beach. This holiday home offers accommodation with a patio.