About this property
Historic Setting: West Neck Guesthouse in Shelter Island Heights offers a unique stay within a historic building. The property features parquet floors and a private entrance, providing a charming atmosphere. Comfortable Accommodations: Rooms include air-conditioning, private bathrooms with free toiletries, and modern amenities such as TV and free WiFi. Guests can relax in the garden or enjoy the balcony with outdoor furniture. Convenient Facilities: The guest house provides free use of bicycles, a fully equipped kitchenette, and free on-site private parking. Additional services include housekeeping and family rooms, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay. Nearby Attractions: Long Island MacArthur Airport is 88 km away, offering easy access to local attractions. The property is highly rated for its room cleanliness and excellent service.
Couples particularly like the location — they rated it 9.0 for a two-person trip.
Distance in property description is calculated using © OpenStreetMap
Most popular facilities
- Free WiFi
- Free parking
- Family rooms
- Tea/coffee maker in all rooms
Guest reviews
Categories:
Select topics to read reviews:
Guests who stayed here loved
- Gabrielle
United States
“A well renovated old house. All white, with a very comfy mattress, nice crisp ironed sheets and large bathroom. Very clean and bright with windows on three sides. The roomy closet had a safe deposit box. Convenient on site parking. Excellent...” - George
United States
“Close to everything, centrally located. So clean and cozy and roomy for small rental. Even had a patio with seats and a small table. Someone came and cleaned each day. Was amazing experience.” - James
United States
“When a property experience is fabulous, there is little more than that one word to properly convey it. This stay will be my go to from here on.” - Kimberly
United States
“Very easy contactless check in, Suzanne was great with communication and accommodating requests and making sure we had a great short trip!” - Yvette
United States
“Very professionally run, grounds were beautifully landscaped, touches such as a note with your name on it, providing check in info. was very thoughtful.”
Host Information

Property surroundings
House rules
Child policies
Children of any age are welcome.
Children 12 years and above will be charged as adults at this property.
To see correct prices and occupancy information, please add the number of children in your group and their ages to your search.
Cot and extra bed policies
Cots and extra beds are not available at this property.




The fine print
Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Please inform West Neck Guesthouse in advance of your expected arrival time. You can use the Special Requests box when booking, or contact the property directly with the contact details provided in your confirmation.