Search hotels on Fire Island, United States

Enter your dates and choose from 25 hotels and other places to stay

Check out these popular cities on Fire Island

Stay in Fire Island's best hotels!

Show hotels on map

Filter by:

Star Rating
Review score

Clegg's Hotel

Hotel in Ocean Beach

Located in Ocean Beach and with Ocean Beach reachable within a 7-minute walk, Clegg's Hotel has concierge services, allergy-free rooms, free bikes, free WiFi and a terrace.

K
KAREN
From
United States
Absolutely loved Clegg's Hotel! Traveled with 2 teens and myself and the location was perfect! Room was spotless and bathrooms were kept spotless. All of the staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Yes, it is a basic room and yes bathrooms are in the hallway. Neither was an issue, and both served their purpose where the beach is the main attraction, and your room is really nothing more than a place to sleep at night.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9
Excellent - What previous guests thought, 44 reviews
Price from
$293.82
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

The Madison Fire Island Pines

Hotel in Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines in Fire Island Pines provides adults-only accommodations with an outdoor swimming pool and a terrace.

D
David
From
United States
I’ve seen other reviews and this they completely undersell this property. It is beautiful, has an excellent location (1 min from FIP ferry) and the facilities, especially the Japanese garden and pool, are stunning. Another review complained about bathroom products; they now have Malin+Goetz, which is a luxury brand. And one mentioned the staff wasn’t friendly: Mike was excellent, made us breakfast, and sangria, so either it was an off day or the customer. Overall, this is the only place I want to stay in FIP.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.0
Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 13 reviews
Price from
$265.65
1 night, 2 adults
Check availability

Grove Hotel

Hotel in Cherry Grove

Grove Hotel in Cherry Grove provides adults only accommodations with a restaurant and a bar.

K
Kyle
From
United States
awesome location, convenient to all major cherry grove businesses and short walking distance to pines water taxis. very clean and sizeable rooms. very comfortable.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.8
Excellent - What previous guests thought, 135 reviews
Check availability

The Pines Men-Only Stay

Hotel in Fire Island Pines

The Pines Men-Only Stay is a recently renovated homestay in Fire Island Pines where guests can make the most of its outdoor swimming pool and terrace.

M
Michael
From
United States
Quiet area, well maintained property.
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.4
Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 49 reviews
Check availability

Sea La Vie

Hotel in Ocean Beach

Sea La Vie offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, a 5-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. Featuring a restaurant, the property also has a shared lounge as well as a hot tub.

J
John
From
United States
Such a wonderful place to stay! Has the whole family and it was so spacious!!
Scored out of 10, guest rating 6.4
Pleasant - What previous guests thought, 9 reviews
Check availability
See all 25 hotels on Fire Island

Planning a trip? Get inspired by reviews of cities on Fire Island

  • 10.0

    More inclusive than the Pines, Cherry Grove is a special...

    More inclusive than the Pines, Cherry Grove is a special queer retreat from NYC. Worth a quick trip, even for a night or 2. Recommend traveling mid-week, non-holidays for better deals on overnight stays and a more relaxing atmosphere.
    Guest review by
    Zachary
    United States
  • 10.0

    I've been going to ocean beach for years. We love it there.

    I've been going to ocean beach for years. We love it there. We look forward to going every year.. people are so nice & friendly.. pancakes at Racheals are wonderful. We plan on going there every year...
    Guest review by
    Anonymous
  • 10.0

    My daughter and I have been visiting Ocean Bay Park for the...

    My daughter and I have been visiting Ocean Bay Park for the past 15 years as a girls weekend. I just love the peacefulness, the location, the beaches, restaurants, etc. This year I decided to rent an airbnb to invite family and friends to spend the time with us that they always hear about!
    Guest review by
    Nancy
    United States